Showing posts with label Options. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Options. Show all posts

Friday, February 19, 2010

The Secrets of Skewness

A question came up the other day regarding how to think about skewness in the volatility surface of equity options.

Thinking of volatility skew as approximated by the relative slope of the volatility surface for a given time to expiry, the
skew can be a valuable indicator that shows option traders' biases towards a particular stock or index. Expensive options are a strong indicator of pending changes in a stock's price. The measure of expensiveness is the options implied volatility.

The ATM or vega-weighted implied volatility measure tells only whether the overall stock volatility is high, but doesn't yield any information about the markets sentiment of the stock's impending directional movement.


Under a Black-Scholes framework, options of the same maturity should in theory have the same implied volatility across strikes. However, in reality this is not the case. Supply-demand dynamics for individu
al option contracts can distort the price (and thus implied vol) at different points across the volatility surface's term structure and strike range.

The disparity of implied volatility between calls / puts indicates the position of traders in aggregate (volume alone does not imply net buying or selling).
For instance, if OTM call ivol is higher than same strike/expiry put ivol, it may imply that traders favor an increase in the underlying.

To really understand the implications of volatility skew for impending price
movements, one needs to analyze the volume of individual option contracts. Here is where volume can add color:

  • High volume and low volatility may indicate that option contracts are being sold.
  • High volume and high volatility may indicate that option contracts are being purchased.

    Additionally, it is important to consider
    Time Skew vs. Strike Skew:

  • Time Skew: measures the spread between option ivol for contracts with same strike but different time to expiry.
  • Strike skew: measure of spread in ivol for contracts with different strikes, but same time to expiry

Together, combining Implied Volatility and Volume, we can infer the following relationships:

  • Higher ivols in NTM / ITM calls vs. puts may indicate a majority of call buyers, which can be viewed as bullish.
  • An abundance of volume in the OTM call, coupled with low ivol, can indicate OTM call sellers. While this is a relatively neutral indicator of direction, it may suggest that traders aren't anticipating the stock rising beyond the OTM call's strike price.
So, what does this all mean in practice, what is the skew of the S&P 500 (SPX) telling us now, and are options "fairly" priced today?

While,
except for a brief respite in mid-November, equity index options have not been this fairly valued in nearly a year (measuring IVOL/30D HVOL), meaning that realized volatility has more closely matched the volatility implied by options prices (see chart at right).

From a distribution standpoint, the ratio is relatively middle of the road, at a 44th-percentile relative to the past year (see histogram at right).



I constructed an equal-weighted index that looks at 80%, 90%, 95%, 105%, 110% and 120% strike options' implied volatility relative to the
ATM implied volatility. The index captures the degree of slope, or skew, in the ivol term structure on any given day.

In looking at the past year's distribution of this index, we see that today the degree of skew in the SPX is incredibly high, or a 5th-percentile event (see charts at right). This high-degree of skew has persisted well over the past month.

However, SPX skew is the highest among global indices, despite extensive focus on the deteriorating macros of Europe and concerns over China. Furthermore, an important implication is that SPX correlation has nearly doubled, which can be seen to indicate the degree to which the market has focused more exclusively on the macro. This coupled with a flattening of the VIX term structure (at right) due to upward pressure on spot/near-term contracts may be indicative of market expectations for higher volatility due to an impending pull-back.

The sovereign macro risks seem to be inherently driving the market...

Thursday, January 7, 2010

Getting Back to Business!

After a much needed respite from exams, it's time to get back to business.

Let's start the New Year by discussing updates to the portfolio over the past four weeks.

The Gold Trade:
It looks like the violent interruption in gold's strong trend during early December was likely just a reversion to the mean. It was during that correction that GLD options appeared to be reasonably priced relative to the past several months (see Chart #1, at right). However, it looks like the short-term will be characterized by turbulent trading, with a skew toward the upside (see Chart #2, at right).

The fundamental rationale for being long-gold (ideally not in USD-terms) still seems intact. As highlighted in today's Gartman Letter, the logic behind the problematic nature of the EUR as a reserve currency strengthens the notion of owning gold, not in US dollar terms but in terms of the EUR, Sterling and the Yen (particularly in light of recent comments made by Naoto Kan, the newly appointed Finance Minister in Japan). Gold is now being seen by more and more governments as reserve currency. More so, with a weakened EuroZone, which is increasingly threatened by the weighing divergence from member nations' (i.e., the PIIGs), it would seem reasonable that capital, which may have been earmarked for euro-denominated assets, on the margin, may more likely be allocated to gold denominated in euro terms.

Energy - Fundamental Book: XTO Bought up by XOM
On Dec-14, ExxonMobil (XOM) announced that it had reached an agreement to buy XTO Energy in an all-stock transaction valued at $41 billion, including approximately $10 billion of XTO debt. The deal implies a ~25% premium for XTO shareholders based on Dec-11 prices.

I first recommended getting long XTO's equity and neutral on CDS in early Mar-09. The thesis was that XTO was more highly levered than peers, and the market was uncertain that they could successfully digest their mammoth acquisitions of 2008 and develop the acquired resources successfully.

However, from a technicals standpoint, XTO initially underperformed relative to key peer Anadarko (APC) by nearly 22% over the subsequent 5 weeks due to crude's nearly 25% rally. After some humbling analysis, I discovered the reason was related to XTO's tighter correlation to natural gas prices and greater hedging toward crude. However, this exercise validated that the underlying fundamental thesis was still intact: because of XTO's best-in-class hedging program and strong management expertise, they would likely maintain the flexibility to successfully development acquired resources on schedule in 2009 while reducing debt through stronger-than-expected operating cash flows. The market had not appreciated their strong CF position via hedging and operational expertise.

XTO's strategic move to acquire promising, high-profile shale assets in 2008 (45 Tcfe resource base and 14 Tcfe of proved reserves at YE08) has paid off. The transaction price comes out to about $0.90 / Mcfe of 3P (proved, probable and possible) reserves and ~$2.88/Mcfe of proved reserves.

In the end, gross of hedging costs (which detracted approximately 950 bps from performance; Jun-09 38 strike ATM puts bought in advance of May 6, 2009 earnings call), the trade returned approximately 48% cumulative, or 78% annualized.

Looking at the bigger picture, the deal meaningfully expands Exxon’s exposure to North America natural gas prices and unconventional natural gas resources. North America unconventional gas has been dominated by the E&P companies, most notably XTO and CHK amongst many others. Now, Exxon will need to demonstrate that it can develop XTO’s resources at an even lower all-in cost than XTO. I would not be surprised if this is the catalyst which sets off massive M&A activity in the shale space, particularly as the Majors look to secure a longer-term energy outlook amidst record low NG prices.

Technical Options Trade: Short Brazil via EWZ Puts
The long Brazilian Jan-10 80 strike ATM EWZ put position, recommended on Dec-2 was closed on Dec-8 when the +/- 40% PnL threshold was reached (this is my internal trading guideline for 1M ATM options where time to expiry is greater than 20 days). Again, I failed to participate in even further upside due, perhaps, to too conservative risk limits and return thresholds; had I held on to the position until Dec-21 (theoretically assuming perfect market timing), the position would have generated twice the return, with 79.6% cumulatively over a three week period. As I get more experience under my belt, I will come back to re-evaluate these guidelines, but in the meantime, the over-arching credo is that the market can remain irrational far longer than I can remain solvent... so, I'll stick to the side of prudence in the meantime.

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Trade Update: "Going for the Gold" - Part II

Well, I left money on the table. What can I say. I exited the directionally long GLD and long GLD Gamma trade a day too early, and missed out on an additional 1.35 of upside today alone.

While I am thrilled with how well the trade worked out already, my naivete reminds me of Lefevre's old adage to follow the path of least resistance; I had been to caught up in the short-term horizon of this trade, that I forgot to acknowledge the influence of the longer-term momentum.

It is bitter sweet to have closed out of the position. This has been my largest trade to date, on a risk-weighted basis, comprising ~12% of portfolio 20-day VaR / PML - the upper threshold of my internal trading guidelines. Now without another week of sleepless nights, I can re-focus my efforts back to my core strategies.

While I still believe there are reasonable fundamentals underlying the demand for Gold, I do believe there is a non-negligible probability of jump risk given that this rally seems to be catalyzed by a crowded USD-carry trade and the potential for a strengthening dollar (Friday's job report will be key). A short squeeze on the Short Dollar-Long Risk trade, as talked about in Mauldin, seems inevitable but not imminent. If the U.S. economy begins to mend itself ahead of schedule, the potential for rate increases will be dollar positive-gold negative; again, the unemployment rate will serve as our barometer for indications of FOMC posturing. Now that I have reduced risk, I am thinking about ways to quantitatively express my fundamental views on this jump risk, particularly in E.M., perhaps via deep OTM puts and long-vol expressions on E.M. ETFs? Brazilian puts (EWZ) or short Chinese Real Estate (TAO) anyone? I also want to re-shift my focus back onto natural gas as we get into the winter draw season. More to come...

Tuesday, November 24, 2009

Going for the Gold


The decline in the dollar and the low interest rate environment are clearly affecting asset prices globally. Capital is fleeing the dollar and flowing everywhere else. While gold has certainly been a beneficiary of this technical rally (price chart at right), its rise has been built on reasonable fundamentals and real demand.
While gold may seem to be structurally overbought (perhaps thanks to the margined prop desks and other carry traders?) there may be some near-term opportunities to build a stronger position. The thesis is as follows:

1. Since March, capital flowed out of risk-less and into risky assets

2. Foreign risk takers needed to hedge their USD exposure of these risky investments, thus exacerbating the dollars decline.

3. Risk has become fundamentally under priced in recent weeks (LIBOR-OIS spreads had dropped back down to pre-Lehman levels earlier this month).

4. Now, sentiment is beginning to shift back to fundamentals

5. We may see a technical pull-back with year-end window

dressing ahead

6. Given the lagged nature in changing correlation structure, the GLD-SPY positive correlation may be expected to hold during a short-term market correction. This will be an opportunity to add to a hedged position in Gold (vis-a-vis the GLD) that will benefit from the long-term macro picture in the U.S. and abroad.

Gold has continued to set newer highs in nominal terms with reasonable fundamentals (i.e., there is increasing real, physical demand for the asset).

Price action in the GLD underlying has been roughly in-line with the expectations given by

option prices, but in recent days, the volatility skew is suggesting increased put buying (see volatility analysis at right), which may be indicative of bearish sentiment in advance of a pullback.

Additionally, the CBOE's gold volatility index (GVZ) has been fluctuating between 20-30 since late August, and the spread between 20D HVOL of GLD and 20D lagged IVOL on GLD has not changed meaningfully in the past several weeks.

Most interestingly, since March, Gold has shifted polarity, becoming highly correlated with the S&P500 (SPY). From a ratio perspective, the GLD/SPY ratio is below recent historical highs.

I am keeping my eyes on theATM Dec-09 115 calls (expiring in 25 days), which have pulled back 22.3% since Monday's gap-open on the GLD (GS quote at $2.36). The ratio of 25d IVOL to HVOL is is in from the wides of 1.6x last week, now at 1.38x (21.26% iVol and 15.46% hVol, annualized).