Showing posts with label ETF. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ETF. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 2, 2009

Trade Update: "Going for the Gold" - Part II

Well, I left money on the table. What can I say. I exited the directionally long GLD and long GLD Gamma trade a day too early, and missed out on an additional 1.35 of upside today alone.

While I am thrilled with how well the trade worked out already, my naivete reminds me of Lefevre's old adage to follow the path of least resistance; I had been to caught up in the short-term horizon of this trade, that I forgot to acknowledge the influence of the longer-term momentum.

It is bitter sweet to have closed out of the position. This has been my largest trade to date, on a risk-weighted basis, comprising ~12% of portfolio 20-day VaR / PML - the upper threshold of my internal trading guidelines. Now without another week of sleepless nights, I can re-focus my efforts back to my core strategies.

While I still believe there are reasonable fundamentals underlying the demand for Gold, I do believe there is a non-negligible probability of jump risk given that this rally seems to be catalyzed by a crowded USD-carry trade and the potential for a strengthening dollar (Friday's job report will be key). A short squeeze on the Short Dollar-Long Risk trade, as talked about in Mauldin, seems inevitable but not imminent. If the U.S. economy begins to mend itself ahead of schedule, the potential for rate increases will be dollar positive-gold negative; again, the unemployment rate will serve as our barometer for indications of FOMC posturing. Now that I have reduced risk, I am thinking about ways to quantitatively express my fundamental views on this jump risk, particularly in E.M., perhaps via deep OTM puts and long-vol expressions on E.M. ETFs? Brazilian puts (EWZ) or short Chinese Real Estate (TAO) anyone? I also want to re-shift my focus back onto natural gas as we get into the winter draw season. More to come...

Wednesday, November 11, 2009

Are WTI's days over?


At the end of October, Saudi Aramco announced their decision to abandon the Platt's WTI-based benchmarks in favor of Argus' new sour crude / U.S. gulf coast index, largely out of fears for future capacity limitations at Cushing. This begs the question of how substantial the current and future shift in momentum will be away from WTI-based benchmarks.

I initially believed the short-term effect of this change would likely be minimal, particularly given that there is no real liquid alternative to the NYMEX/CME WTI contract. Additionally, the debate around Cushing as a suitable delivery point has been going on for years.

However, I am beginning to re-evaluate my medium-to-longterm thesis based upon the following recent data points:

(1) Shifts in open interest suggest a subtle trend away from WTI is already underway: there has already been a subtle shift away from trading activity in WTI to Brent this year, as confirmed in the open interest figures.
(2) New ETF instruments will open additional avenues to route capital away from WTI: new news that UNG / USO's parent, the United States Commodity Fund, has announcement a potential launch of an ETF tied to the Argus sour crude index. While this likely won't replace USO, the dramatic growth of USO is a testament that there may be substantial demand for this type of product, and;
(3) New CME futures contract will have the largest impact on liquidity shifting away from WTI: CME's expectation to likely launch new contract at the end of the year to capitalize on the success of the Argus Index. It would be interesting to see the curve dynamics and level of contango that come about under this new contract, as this may not only present some interesting relative value trades with WTI dynamics, but if the contango is more favorable, perhaps we will see a shift out of USO and into the new ETF products.

As crude has been used by investors as less of a physical asset, and more of a global financial asset in recent years, it would seem reasonable that the commodities physical limitations would ultimately lead to natural market frictions. After all, there is only so much storage, and as such, Oklahoma cannot continue to be the best entry point forever.